AP Processing Challenge No. 10 - The Triangulum Galaxy

Every month a new challenge!
User avatar
Graeme1858 Great Britain
Co-Administrator
Co-Administrator
Articles: 1
Online
Posts: 7217
Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2019 7:16 pm
4
Location: North Kent, UK
Status:
Online

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

I Broke The Forum.

AP Processing Challenge No. 10 - The Triangulum Galaxy

#1

Post by Graeme1858 »


Welcome to:

AP Processing Challenge No. 10

Bobharmony has submitted his capture of M33, The Triangulum Galaxy.

Wikipedia: The Triangulum Galaxy is a spiral galaxy 2.73 million light-years from Earth in the constellation Triangulum. It is catalogued as Messier 33 or NGC 598. The Triangulum Galaxy is the third-largest member of the Local Group of galaxies, behind the Milky Way and the Andromeda Galaxy.

"This was collected on 9/21/2020. 77 180 second lights, 81 flats, 81 dark flats. I didn't have any darks at the right temp, so I went without. Collected with the C6N and Canon unmodded 60D. Stacked in DSS K=3, S=8. No color calibration or white balancing of any kind done in stacking."

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ ... sp=sharing

Just click the link above to download and process Bob's image using your preferred software and methods.

AP Processing Challenge No. 10 starts today and ends on the 15th November.

Please keep the submissions coming in for future challenges. Just send a PM to a Mod or an email to:

tssapchallenge@theskysearchers.com

And don't forget Challenge No 9 is still running. If you haven't already, have a go at processing Bradley Craig's excellent narrow band, widefield images of the North America and Pelican nebulas.

Have fun!

Regards

Graeme
______________________________________________
Celestron 9.25 f10 SCT, f6.3FR, CGX mount.
ASI1600MM Pro, ASI294MC Pro, ASI224MC
ZWO EFW, ZWO OAG, ASI220MM Mini.
APM 11x70 ED APO Binoculars.

https://www.averywayobservatory.co.uk/
User avatar
bobharmony
Local Group Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 2028
Joined: Sun May 12, 2019 1:11 pm
4
Location: Connecticut, US
Status:
Offline

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#2

Post by bobharmony »


Here is a brief description of the data and what's been done with it so far:

This was collected on 9/21/2020. 77 180 second lights, 81 flats, 81 dark flats. I didn't have any darks at the right temp, so I went without.

Collected with the C6N and Canon unmodded 60D. Stacked in DSS K=3, S=8. No color calibration or white balancing of any kind done in stacking.

Bob
Hardware: Celestron C6-N w/ Advanced GTmount, Baader MK iii CC, Orion ST-80, Canon 60D (unmodded), Nikon D5300 (modded), Orion SSAG
Software: BYE, APT, PHD2, DSS, PhotoShop CC 2020, StarTools, Cartes du Ciel, AstroTortilla

Image
User avatar
Ruud
Orion Spur Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 813
Joined: Sun Feb 09, 2020 9:56 pm
4
Location: the Netherlands
Status:
Offline

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#3

Post by Ruud »


Hi guys, thanks for the new contest.

I have a download problem:
     First I get a message box saying there is no preview. It has a download button. I click it.
     Then I get a message box saying there will be no virus check. A button says 'download anyway'. I click that.
And then I get first message box again, I click, I get the second message box, I click, the first message box, I click
and so on. Much like Groundhog Day.

I haven't been able to download the files yet. Does anyone else have this happening?
7x50 Helios Apollo 8x42 Bresser Everest 73mm f/5.9 WO APO 4" f/5 TeleVue Genesis 6" f/10 Celestron 6SE 0.63x reducer 1.8, 2, 2.5 and 3x Barlows eyepieces from 4.5 to 34mm
User avatar
bobharmony
Local Group Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 2028
Joined: Sun May 12, 2019 1:11 pm
4
Location: Connecticut, US
Status:
Offline

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#4

Post by bobharmony »


I was able to download the file with no problem. I see the "no virus check" message, click "download anyway", and down it comes. Win 10 laptop, Firefox Browser.

Bob
Hardware: Celestron C6-N w/ Advanced GTmount, Baader MK iii CC, Orion ST-80, Canon 60D (unmodded), Nikon D5300 (modded), Orion SSAG
Software: BYE, APT, PHD2, DSS, PhotoShop CC 2020, StarTools, Cartes du Ciel, AstroTortilla

Image
User avatar
Graeme1858 Great Britain
Co-Administrator
Co-Administrator
Articles: 1
Online
Posts: 7217
Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2019 7:16 pm
4
Location: North Kent, UK
Status:
Online

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

I Broke The Forum.

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#5

Post by Graeme1858 »


Ruud wrote: Fri Oct 16, 2020 1:57 pm Much like Groundhog Day.

Hello Rudd.

I just tried the link again. I get the same scenario as you describe and when I click Download anyway the first message box appears again but at the same time the file downloads. Could you check your Download folder for Challenge No 10 - Bobharmony - Triangulum Galaxy.fts

Regards

Graeme
______________________________________________
Celestron 9.25 f10 SCT, f6.3FR, CGX mount.
ASI1600MM Pro, ASI294MC Pro, ASI224MC
ZWO EFW, ZWO OAG, ASI220MM Mini.
APM 11x70 ED APO Binoculars.

https://www.averywayobservatory.co.uk/
User avatar
bradleybcraig
Jupiter Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 224
Joined: Tue Jul 16, 2019 10:23 am
4
Location: Charlotte, North Carolina, USA
Status:
Offline

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#6

Post by bradleybcraig »


Thanks for the data Bob!! Going to give it a whirl - what was the focal length and the pixel size of your camera?
-Brad

Hardware: Meade 8" ACF, Mallincam CF VRC-8 & 0.75 reducer w/ Moonlite 2" CS focuser & High Res Stepper, WO Star 71 w/ Moonlite High Res Stepper,
iOptron CEM60, Modified Canon 450D, Atik 383L+ mono, Lodestar X2, 2" Atik EFW2, Astrodon 36mm 3nm NB Ha/Sii/Oiii Filters, LRGB Gen2 E-Series Tru-Balance Filters, PoleMaster
Software: SkySafari Pro, Sequence Generator Pro, PHD2, PixInsight
Astrobin: https://www.astrobin.com/users/a028964/
Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/bradleycr ... roimaging/
User avatar
bobharmony
Local Group Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 2028
Joined: Sun May 12, 2019 1:11 pm
4
Location: Connecticut, US
Status:
Offline

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#7

Post by bobharmony »


bradleybcraig wrote: Fri Oct 16, 2020 4:23 pm Thanks for the data Bob!! Going to give it a whirl - what was the focal length and the pixel size of your camera?
Hi Brad -f/l is 750mm, pixel size 4.3um. I think the works out to 1.2arcsec/pixel and my best seeing is about 2 arcsec (3 average), so we are a bit oversampled, but not by much.

Bob
Hardware: Celestron C6-N w/ Advanced GTmount, Baader MK iii CC, Orion ST-80, Canon 60D (unmodded), Nikon D5300 (modded), Orion SSAG
Software: BYE, APT, PHD2, DSS, PhotoShop CC 2020, StarTools, Cartes du Ciel, AstroTortilla

Image
User avatar
bradleybcraig
Jupiter Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 224
Joined: Tue Jul 16, 2019 10:23 am
4
Location: Charlotte, North Carolina, USA
Status:
Offline

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#8

Post by bradleybcraig »


Here is my go at it in PixInsight. Processing steps ... Very nice data Bob! Thanks for letting me play :-)
Challenge_No_10_Bobharmony_Triangulum_Galaxy.jpg
1. Crop
2. Several DBEs for background modeling and gradient removal
3. Extract Luminance for later processing
4. BackgroundNeutralization on RGB
5. PhotometicColorCalibration on RGB
6. SCNR for greens on RGB
7. MultiscaleLinearTransform on RGB for linear noise reduction with mask
8. Iterative HistogramTransformations on RGB for non-linear
9. Final SCNR on RGB
10. Several CurveTransformations on RGB w/ mask to adjust RGB and Saturation curves
11. MultiscaleLinearTansformation on Luminance for linear noise reduction with mask
12. MaskedStretch followed by iterative HistogramTransformations on Luminance for non-linear
13. CurvesTransformation on Luminance to adjust RGB curve - s-curve shape
14. ACDNR for mild noise reduction on Luminance
15. UnsharpMask on Luminance with mask for sharpening in galaxy.
16. LRGBCombination to overlay Luminance on RGB - increased saturation and applied chrominance noise reduction
17. Final ColorSaturation with mask to boost blue and red.
-Brad

Hardware: Meade 8" ACF, Mallincam CF VRC-8 & 0.75 reducer w/ Moonlite 2" CS focuser & High Res Stepper, WO Star 71 w/ Moonlite High Res Stepper,
iOptron CEM60, Modified Canon 450D, Atik 383L+ mono, Lodestar X2, 2" Atik EFW2, Astrodon 36mm 3nm NB Ha/Sii/Oiii Filters, LRGB Gen2 E-Series Tru-Balance Filters, PoleMaster
Software: SkySafari Pro, Sequence Generator Pro, PHD2, PixInsight
Astrobin: https://www.astrobin.com/users/a028964/
Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/bradleycr ... roimaging/
User avatar
Graeme1858 Great Britain
Co-Administrator
Co-Administrator
Articles: 1
Online
Posts: 7217
Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2019 7:16 pm
4
Location: North Kent, UK
Status:
Online

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

I Broke The Forum.

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#9

Post by Graeme1858 »


That's really nice Bradley.

And your workflow list is very helpful too.

You have a great colour balance, I had a quick go at it this morning but then I got distracted! I had the green cast so I was going to have another go by opening in Gimp in channels to play with the curves separately. The colour balance didn't sort it. What is SCNR? (I searched for it and got "sorry, could not resist")

Regards

Graeme
______________________________________________
Celestron 9.25 f10 SCT, f6.3FR, CGX mount.
ASI1600MM Pro, ASI294MC Pro, ASI224MC
ZWO EFW, ZWO OAG, ASI220MM Mini.
APM 11x70 ED APO Binoculars.

https://www.averywayobservatory.co.uk/
User avatar
Gordon United States of America
Site Admin
Site Admin
Articles: 1037
Offline
Posts: 8266
Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:52 pm
4
Location: Cottonwood, AZ
Status:
Offline

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

I Broke The Forum.

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#10

Post by Gordon »


I thought I would give this one a shot.
My-copy-Challenge-No-10---B.jpg
Processed in StarTools:
Image size is 4278 x 2864
---
Type of Data: Linear, was not Bayered, or was Bayered + white balanced
--- Auto Develop
default
--- Bin
bin to 2139 x 1432
--- Crop
Crop to 1473 x 799
--- Wipe
Default
--- Develop
Adjust to best combination
--- Contrast
default
--- Psycho-Visual Grain Equalization De-Noise
Parameter [Grain Size] set to [2.0 pixels]
--- Repair
Default
____ Color
I did a little tweaking to reduce a blue color cast on the galaxy.
File saved
Gordon
Scopes: Explore Scientific ED80CF, Skywatcher 200 Quattro Imaging Newt, SeeStar S50 for EAA.
Mounts: Orion Atlas EQ-g mount & Skywatcher EQ5 Pro.
ZWO mini guider.
Image cameras: ZWO ASI1600 MM Cool, ZWO ASI533mc-Pro, ZWO ASI174mm-C (for use with my Quark chromosphere), ZWO ASI120MC
Filters: LRGB, Ha 7nm, O-III 7nm, S-II 7nm
Eyepieces: a few.
Primary software: Cartes du Ciel, N.I.N.A, StarTools V1.4.

Image
User avatar
Graeme1858 Great Britain
Co-Administrator
Co-Administrator
Articles: 1
Online
Posts: 7217
Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2019 7:16 pm
4
Location: North Kent, UK
Status:
Online

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

I Broke The Forum.

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#11

Post by Graeme1858 »


That's a nice clean look Gordon.

Does Startools natrally keep the colouring subtle? Or is that a result of your tweaking?

Psycho-Visual Grain Equalization De-Noise sounds intriguing!

Regards

Graeme
______________________________________________
Celestron 9.25 f10 SCT, f6.3FR, CGX mount.
ASI1600MM Pro, ASI294MC Pro, ASI224MC
ZWO EFW, ZWO OAG, ASI220MM Mini.
APM 11x70 ED APO Binoculars.

https://www.averywayobservatory.co.uk/
User avatar
Gordon United States of America
Site Admin
Site Admin
Articles: 1037
Offline
Posts: 8266
Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2019 10:52 pm
4
Location: Cottonwood, AZ
Status:
Offline

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

I Broke The Forum.

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#12

Post by Gordon »


Graeme1858 wrote: Sat Oct 17, 2020 9:23 pm That's a nice clean look Gordon.

Does Startools natrally keep the colouring subtle? Or is that a result of your tweaking?

Psycho-Visual Grain Equalization De-Noise sounds intriguing!

Regards

Graeme
ST by the default set them pretty strong. I have a tendency to make them more subtle as that’s what I like.
Gordon
Scopes: Explore Scientific ED80CF, Skywatcher 200 Quattro Imaging Newt, SeeStar S50 for EAA.
Mounts: Orion Atlas EQ-g mount & Skywatcher EQ5 Pro.
ZWO mini guider.
Image cameras: ZWO ASI1600 MM Cool, ZWO ASI533mc-Pro, ZWO ASI174mm-C (for use with my Quark chromosphere), ZWO ASI120MC
Filters: LRGB, Ha 7nm, O-III 7nm, S-II 7nm
Eyepieces: a few.
Primary software: Cartes du Ciel, N.I.N.A, StarTools V1.4.

Image
User avatar
Graeme1858 Great Britain
Co-Administrator
Co-Administrator
Articles: 1
Online
Posts: 7217
Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2019 7:16 pm
4
Location: North Kent, UK
Status:
Online

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

I Broke The Forum.

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#13

Post by Graeme1858 »


Here's my go!

Curves and Levels
Colour balance
Saturation
S Curve
Unshsarp mask

Image

I have to say, I'm struggling to get the colours out of the image! I've had a few goes at it and I know the colours are there because they can be seen in the submissions above! Probably a Gimp problem. If I open normally and convert to RGB all colours behave as one. If I open as Colour composing = Naxis 3 (dunno what that means!) then all the signal is in the green channel.

Any suggestions?

I'll have a go in Photoshop 2 tonight.

Regards

Graeme
______________________________________________
Celestron 9.25 f10 SCT, f6.3FR, CGX mount.
ASI1600MM Pro, ASI294MC Pro, ASI224MC
ZWO EFW, ZWO OAG, ASI220MM Mini.
APM 11x70 ED APO Binoculars.

https://www.averywayobservatory.co.uk/
User avatar
Ruud
Orion Spur Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 813
Joined: Sun Feb 09, 2020 9:56 pm
4
Location: the Netherlands
Status:
Offline

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#14

Post by Ruud »


I used Fitswork and Photoshop.

It wasn't easy! But separating the stars with StarNet_Win and using the Topaz plugins on the galaxy revealed some clear detail and even a hint of colour. This is attempt 6. I don't think I can get it any better:

Challenge10Ruud.png
Click for a larger view
7x50 Helios Apollo 8x42 Bresser Everest 73mm f/5.9 WO APO 4" f/5 TeleVue Genesis 6" f/10 Celestron 6SE 0.63x reducer 1.8, 2, 2.5 and 3x Barlows eyepieces from 4.5 to 34mm
User avatar
andrewsscope Great Britain
Saturn Ambassador
Articles: 0
Online
Posts: 395
Joined: Mon May 13, 2019 2:18 pm
4
Location: Basildon Uk
Status:
Online

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#15

Post by andrewsscope »


Hi all I used my Light pollution software first on the image,used Vertical line removal,horizontal line removal.I then created a duplicate layer and used colour and adjusted the levels and deepsky colours for Hlvg.Then I re used my light pollution software for the second time and ended up with this image.Thanks for the data.
m33clour2.jpg
Andy
Telescopes :Skywatcher 80ed,Skywatcher 200p,Altair astro 60mm guidescope
Cameras: Canon 550d,Altair gp cam mono,gp cam 290c
Tripod: Eq5
User avatar
Graeme1858 Great Britain
Co-Administrator
Co-Administrator
Articles: 1
Online
Posts: 7217
Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2019 7:16 pm
4
Location: North Kent, UK
Status:
Online

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

I Broke The Forum.

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#16

Post by Graeme1858 »


Ruud wrote: Mon Oct 19, 2020 7:17 pm I used Fitswork and Photoshop.
It wasn't easy! But separating the stars with StarNet_Win and using the Topaz plugins on the galaxy revealed some clear detail and even a hint of colour. This is attempt 6. I don't think I can get it any better:

Is that the Photoshop Topaz plugin that has brought the blues out?

andrewsscope wrote: Mon Oct 19, 2020 10:42 pm Hi all I used my Light pollution software first on the image,used Vertical line removal,horizontal line removal.I then created a duplicate layer and used colour and adjusted the levels and deepsky colours for Hlvg.Then I re used my light pollution software for the second time and ended up with this image.Thanks for the data.

Is that HLVG that has brought the colour out?

Regards

Graeme
______________________________________________
Celestron 9.25 f10 SCT, f6.3FR, CGX mount.
ASI1600MM Pro, ASI294MC Pro, ASI224MC
ZWO EFW, ZWO OAG, ASI220MM Mini.
APM 11x70 ED APO Binoculars.

https://www.averywayobservatory.co.uk/
User avatar
andrewsscope Great Britain
Saturn Ambassador
Articles: 0
Online
Posts: 395
Joined: Mon May 13, 2019 2:18 pm
4
Location: Basildon Uk
Status:
Online

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#17

Post by andrewsscope »


Hi Graeme I used it as a duplicate layer in Adobe cs2 and used the colorize to bring out the colour by altering the hue and saturation.Thanks Andy
Andy
Telescopes :Skywatcher 80ed,Skywatcher 200p,Altair astro 60mm guidescope
Cameras: Canon 550d,Altair gp cam mono,gp cam 290c
Tripod: Eq5
User avatar
Ruud
Orion Spur Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 813
Joined: Sun Feb 09, 2020 9:56 pm
4
Location: the Netherlands
Status:
Offline

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#18

Post by Ruud »


Graeme1858 wrote: Tue Oct 20, 2020 12:14 pm Is that the Photoshop Topaz plugin that has brought the blues out?
Hi Graeme, no the blue is not from Topaz. Initially, after Fitswork, the image was mainly green. So in PS I separated the R, G and B channels into three 16bit grayscale images. Those I combined as layers in a new RGB image, each in its own group. I added a colour layer and curves layer to each of the three groups, so that I effectively had three colour 'channels' that I could manipulate independently. This was how I got rid of the green cast that I had before. In the blue group I dimmed the brightest tones somewhat so that the stars and core of the galaxy became a bit warmer than the disk.

I made a new top layer that combined the result. From this I separated the stars.

In Topaz Adjust I increased the local luminosity contrast as well as the colour contrast of the galaxy. That brought out much detail and even a few red patches. I used the luminosity and the red details and blended them into the galaxy. I added the stars and that was it.
7x50 Helios Apollo 8x42 Bresser Everest 73mm f/5.9 WO APO 4" f/5 TeleVue Genesis 6" f/10 Celestron 6SE 0.63x reducer 1.8, 2, 2.5 and 3x Barlows eyepieces from 4.5 to 34mm
User avatar
bobharmony
Local Group Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 2028
Joined: Sun May 12, 2019 1:11 pm
4
Location: Connecticut, US
Status:
Offline

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#19

Post by bobharmony »


I haven't been happy with my results so far, so I gave it another try. One of the biggest problems I have had with all my M33 data collected over the past few years is that the gradient seems especially obnoxious in this part of the sky.

I made one change in my StarTools processing this time. When doing the Wipe, I used the Vignetting preset instead of Gradient. It seemed to do a better job in evening out the background.

Process was Bin, Crop, WIpe (vignetting preset), Autodev (with ROI and "ignore fine detail"), deconvolution, HDR, Color, Life, and noise reduction. I am making progress but still not thrilled.
M33 DSS ST vignette PS.jpg
I am going back to DSS and restacking, removing the lights with the highest sky background values. I'll try processing that and put the result in a different thread if there is significant improvement.

Thanks everyone for showing your processes and results. It is always interesting to see what folks can come up with.

Bob
Hardware: Celestron C6-N w/ Advanced GTmount, Baader MK iii CC, Orion ST-80, Canon 60D (unmodded), Nikon D5300 (modded), Orion SSAG
Software: BYE, APT, PHD2, DSS, PhotoShop CC 2020, StarTools, Cartes du Ciel, AstroTortilla

Image
User avatar
Juno16 United States of America
Universal Ambassador
Articles: 0
Offline
Posts: 8195
Joined: Sun May 12, 2019 3:13 pm
4
Location: Mississippi Gulf Coast
Status:
Offline

TSS Awards Badges

TSS Photo of the Day

Re: AP Processing Challenge No. 10

#20

Post by Juno16 »


My quick take. Similar process as yours, Bob, except I tried another Life module at a strength of 25% just to reduce the background unevenness. Dropped the background a bit more in Photoshop using levels.

Pretty much the same result.

Thanks for the opportunity to try a shot at it. I am imaging the Bubble tonight and gave me some exercise while waiting for the meridian flip.

Challenge No 10 - Bobharmony - Triangulum Galaxy.jpg
Jim

Scopes: Explore Scientific ED102 APO, Sharpstar 61 EDPH II APO, Samyang 135 F2 (still on the Nikon).
Mount: Skywatcher HEQ5 Pro with Rowan Belt Mod
Stuff: ASI EAF Focus Motor (x2), Orion 50mm Guide Scope, ZWO 30 mm Guide Scope, ASI 220mm min, ASI 120mm mini, Stellarview 0.8 FR/FF, Sharpstar 0.8 FR/FF, Mele Overloock 3C.
Camera/Filters/Software: ASI 533 mc pro, ASI 120mm mini, Orion SSAG, IDAS LPS D-1, Optolong L-Enhance, ZWO UV/IR Cut, N.I.N.A., Green Swamp Server, PHD2, Adobe Photoshop CC, Pixinsight.
Dog and best bud: Jack
Sky: Bortle 6-7
My Astrobin: https://www.astrobin.com/users/Juno16/
Locked

Return to “AP Processing Challenge”